Sunday, April 29, 2012

~failed~

I get a big fat F on this project.
Remember this picture?
I fell in love with this whole look.
 So, I got the wild idea to paint the apron on my farm table to mimic the one in the picture.
I used 2 greens I had on hand, I think they were mis~tints from long ago.
Then I added a ton of Annie Sloan dark wax.

 I LOVE the color, only problem is, it doesn't match the rug at all.
That's what I get for diving into a project without thinking it through!
Luckily I only did this one short side, so I can easily sand it off or paint over it.
 So, that's the million dollar question.
Do I keep going with the paint, only use a different color?
Or, leave the table au natural? 

{You can see more of our dining room by clicking on the dining room link on the right hand side of this page.}
Thanks for your input!
xoxo

36 comments:

Teri said...

I disagree!!! My girls(young women) are always telling me not to be matchy matchy. I actually love the paint and rug combo. I think the change should be the table legs..not sure if I would lighten or darken them up...lol

kelly lautenbach said...

While you are correct that it doesn't "match", I definitely think it coordinates in an eclectic and collected kind of look and I think that's a better look than a perfectly matched Pottery Barn look. :) I say go forward and paint. I love the way it's looking...

Suzan said...

If the color doesn't work for you, add a little green to move away from the turquoise. That being said, it doesn't look bad exactly the color you painted it. The pop of color looks great!

shannon i olson said...

I like it, just the way it is going!

Miss Hannah B. said...

I think a little lighter mossy green would work well, not so turquoise . But keep painting, I love the look.

Deserae said...

I love it!!! I would ditch the rug and keep on painting :o)
~Des

notmothert said...

I think the color you are painting the table is beautiful. I would find a new rug to coordinate more with the table. I think it's just because its more of a vibrant/pop of color than you are used to having in your kitchen that is throwing you off. Please keep going...I want to see the fnished product!

{ L } said...

I have to agree that, green or natural legs, you replace the rug. I think your new green finish looks fantastic though!

Mona Kay at Blissfully Refurbished said...

I love it!! The contrast and coordination is fabulous.

Anonymous said...

I love the color but Melaine I have been reading your blog for a long time and I think you will get tired of the bright pop of color and change it for something more subtle. With that being said I think you should go with a more muted green (like in the pic) that will still match the rug that you have. The rug is beautiful and paint is less expensive. Jeni

Denise said...

Paint is cheap, so go with the color you love. If you want a more muted tint as in the beautiful rug, then a sage green is lovely. On the other hand, if you love the way this color sings (as I do) then keep painting! I think you just need to decide if you want a matched subtle look or if you like to mix it up with surprises here and there.

Sarah said...

I love it! But I love it when things don't match perfectly. I might steal this idea myself. ;)

Blondie's Journal said...

I think the table is looking wonderful...love the color! You can always get a natural rug like jute or something woven and it would really look farmhousy!

XO,
Jane

Paulette, Jvona & Rachel said...

I think the tones in the rug go perfectly with the color of the table. Like whites, greens go with each other naturally. Think about a desert landscape, and see how many different greens you see. Keep going.
Paulette

Rachel Pallas said...

I think the colour is great but personally I would try to match the green a little more to the rug..if you love the rug and its a keeper. I almost painted the bottom of my farm table this weekend then chickened out! :) Im sure whatever you decide will look great! xo

Sally@Enlightenment for the Sleepy said...

I love it keep painting! It's going to be beautiful, Sally xx

Danielle @ Transforming Home said...

I love it the way it is! I think it coordinates beautifully with the rug. But I am not at all a matchy-matchy person. I think an eclectic pulled-together look is so much more interesting than everything matching. I'm sure whatever you decide to do will be beautiful!

Loi Thai, Tone on Tone said...

Hi Melanie - I just discovered your blog. I saw the post title "failed" and thought I'd read on.

If I may add, I think what you've done with your table looks great!! Would love to see how it turns out. Best of luck!

Cheers from DC,
Loi
Tone on Tone

mimi said...

Love it! Paint on...I think it looks great with the rug!

Anonymous said...

Looks great! Love the color!

Merri Jo said...

If the not matching bugs you now, I'd think it always will-- your paint job is fabulous, though, so I'd recommend just adjusting the color!

Anonymous said...

Melaine,

I am with the crowd who loves a less matchy-matchy look....although I had to laugh at the advice of changing the rug. Rugs are usually more expensive than paint! But of course, that is always an option, if you are not in love with your rug.

If this will continue to bother you, then just "sage it up" a bit. Adjust the color to a more muted shade. I wouldn't do away with the project entirely, though. You are doing a great job!

I would just leave it as is, personally. :)

Amy in CA

haleys cottage said...

How about Annie Sloan Versailles or Chateau Grey??

A Cottage Muse said...

I love the pop of color!

jodi said...

I love it! When you bring something else in the room with that color it will all go together without being too matchy.

Kimberly said...

I love the look you have - just change out the green so it isn't so bright. You have such an eye.

Anonymous said...

I like your green better than the picture green. I need to see the whole picture with the rug, but I would have to say I like it better. Gives a good color pop, and I love that color of blue-green! The staining looks awesome. I dont like things to perfectly match anyway. Keep going. (and where do you get all your energy?)

Tracy

karen said...

Ok..so, it looks like you have many suggestions but I'll throw my 2 cents in...why not!
I would change the paint color to a more earthy green..mossy? But I would do it VERY chippy! That way you haven't lost the natural tone of your table but you get that Hint of color! Hope this makes sense to you?! Good luck whatever direction you go!

stacy said...

The table looks fabulous!!!!!
You could always use that rug in a different room and get a new one for your table.
I could never re-create that look on the table. Please give a step by step on how you achieved that look!

La Maison Fou said...

You know sample experimenting with color proves to be the mother of all invention......I am throwing my hat in with a less matched color scheme.....and I like the contrast!

In the long run, you are correct, paint is cheap and a very forgiving medium!
Trudge on!

Leslie

Between You and Me said...

well....are you gonna keep painting or go natural?

I love your inspiration picture and I think it's a great idea to have that part of the table painted a color.....the color you have on there is beautiful but I totally get it that you think the color is off.
Sometimes a color in a picture isn't what it really looks like in person.

You're awesome at all of this...I'm sure it'll all come together...just be sure to show us pictures of your finished project. :)

Sue@pineapplehillinteriors said...

Don't stress about it. It's only paint and it looks great! The table will be the pop of color and the rug will fade into the background. I love that table.I stop by often to check out your dining room.

Anonymous said...

I love the way the table is looking more than the rug. I agree with a few others that suggested you change the green to be a bit more earthy. The green in your inspiration pic would look nice with your rug. But I'll be honest, when I saw the very first picture my initial reaction was, "She needs a new rug!"

Danielle said...

Whoa-stop the presses!

First- your dining room rug is soooo clean and beautiful!

Second- I spy some fabulous stone tile under there that's should be in the spotlight with that table!!!!

I am sure the rug could be moved or stored but not forgotten:)

Exxxxtra Credit- You always do A+ work!
Danielle M.

KellyH said...

I love love that table. Maybe it's just the picture, but I think it looks good with the rug.

Jill Flory of Sew a Fine Seam said...

My first thought is if you like the green on the table just get a new rug! If you don't want to get a new rug then I would definitely use a different paint on the table instead of leaving it natural. I love the look of paint and natural and I really like all the dark wax you used.
And another thing - I don't think in necessarily has to match the rug. Unless it hurts your eyes every time you look at it, I wouldn't worry about it matching!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...